Whose Idea Was It?

[NBT]

I don't know, but I think you guys are giving Marinelli's defense too much credit. Maybe Cadams is right, as well as Kravix, that Kubiak gets too conservative when we are ahead like we were.

[Keith]

Originally Posted by NBT

Maybe Cadams is right, as well as Kravix, that Kubiak gets too conservative when we are ahead like we were.

I'm not sure they got too conservative. Here is the PBP of the Texans' two drives after going up 28-10.

1-10-HOU 33 (:13) 30-A.Green left guard to HOU 35 for 2 yards (55-R.Nece).
END QUARTER 3
2-8-HOU 35 (15:00) 8-M.Schaub pass incomplete short left to 80-A.Johnson (25-B.Kelly).
3-8-HOU 35 (14:55) (Shotgun) 30-A.Green up the middle to HOU 49 for 14 yards (50-E.Sims, 27-D.Bullocks).
1-10-HOU 49 (14:10) 8-M.Schaub FUMBLES (Aborted) at HOU 47, and recovers at HOU 47. 8-M.Schaub to HOU 47 for no gain (75-S.Cody).
2-12-HOU 47 (13:33) 20-S.Slaton left tackle to HOU 46 for -1 yards (75-S.Cody, 99-D.White).
3-13-HOU 46 (12:48) 8-M.Schaub pass short left to 83-K.Walter to 50 for 4 yards (38-R.Robinson, 25-B.Kelly).
4-9- (12:07) 1-M.Turk punts 46 yards to DET 4, Center-48-B.Pittman, downed by HOU-11-A.Davis. (Punt hang time is 4.8 seconds.)

1-10-HOU 22 (11:39) 8-M.Schaub pass deep left to 80-A.Johnson to HOU 40 for 18 yards (28-L.Bodden).
1-10-HOU 40 (10:52) 20-S.Slaton right guard to HOU 45 for 5 yards (78-C.Redding).
2-5-HOU 45 (10:08) 20-S.Slaton right end to HOU 43 for -2 yards (75-S.Cody). DET-78-C.Redding was injured during the play.
3-7-HOU 43 (9:28) (Shotgun) 8-M.Schaub pass incomplete short right to 83-K.Walter.
4-7-HOU 43 (9:20) 1-M.Turk punts 54 yards to DET 3, Center-48-B.Pittman, downed by HOU-28-A.Molden. Penalty on DET-59-A.Lewis, Running Into the Kicker, declined. (Punt hang time is 4.4 seconds.)

I don't see much there overly conservative, other than the (yes, effective) handoff on third down out of the shotgun to Green.

The third and final drive was predictability conservative as they were trying to eat up the clock with Ahman Green runs.

1-10-HOU 26 (4:10) 30-A.Green right guard to HOU 35 for 9 yards (99-D.White, 27-D.Bullocks).
2-1-HOU 35 (3:24) 30-A.Green right guard to HOU 35 for no gain (99-D.White, 55-R.Nece).
3-1-HOU 35 (2:40) 30-A.Green left tackle to HOU 36 for 1 yard (99-D.White, 95-J.DeVries).
Two-Minute Warning
1-10-HOU 36 (2:00) 30-A.Green left tackle to HOU 37 for 1 yard (78-C.Redding).
Timeout #3 by DET at 01:55.
2-9-HOU 37 (1:55) 30-A.Green left tackle to HOU 44 for 7 yards (24-K.Pearson, 35-L.Hicks).
3-2-HOU 44 (1:09) PENALTY on HOU-74-E.Salaam, False Start, 5 yards, enforced at HOU 44 - No Play.
3-7-HOU 39 (1:06) 30-A.Green up the middle to HOU 39 for no gain (50-E.Sims, 79-L.Moore).
Timeout #1 by HOU at 00:20.
4-7-HOU 39 (:20) 1-M.Turk punts 59 yards to DET 2, Center-48-B.Pittman, downed by HOU-11-A.Davis.

Given they ran the clock all the way down to 20 seconds from 4:10, it seems like the conservative approach paid off here, perhaps even moreso had Salaam not been called for the foul start.

The Lions came back mostly because of a lapse in defense (coughCalvinJohnsonisafreakingstudcough), not because the offensive playcalling went into a shell.

[popanot]

Whoever was at fault for not having S help over the top on that play hopefully got a tongue lashing - or worse. I can see a DB getting beat by CJ in that situation, but it was inexcusable for there not to be a Safety in close proximity to tackle or not knock him out of bounds. I mean the Lions were at 2yd line and had to go the whole damn field in order to score. For a coach or player to get fooled or to 'bite' on the run in that instance is just insane. How badly is a running play going to hurt you in that situation? Dumb football, indeed.

[papabear]

Originally Posted by popanot

Whoever was at fault for not having S help over the top on that play hopefully got a tongue lashing - or worse. I can see a DB getting beat by CJ in that situation, but it was inexcusable for there not to be a Safety in close proximity to tackle or not knock him out of bounds. I mean the Lions were at 2yd line and had to go the whole damn field in order to score. For a coach or player to get fooled or to 'bite' on the run in that instance is just insane. How badly is a running play going to hurt you in that situation? Dumb football, indeed.

Supposedly we were in quarter quarter half coverage...which means he was all Petey's down the sideline. Check the discussion in the comments here...

http://www.atexansblog.com/2008/10/2...rage/#comments

[NBT]

If Keith is correct and he probably is, then coach Gibbs needs to get more out of the Olinemen and the RBs during crunch time if we are going to run the clock out. Maybe that is what we are all alluding to.