The Safeties

[KJ3]

i don't think dunta is a playmaker. he's about as solid of a cover corner as you can ask for but i don't think he's the type of player that routinely changes how offenses play. what's the most interceptions he's ever had?

EDIT: it's 6. with 19 passes deflected, 3 forced fumbles, 3 sacks, 74 tackles with 14 assists. that was 2004, the only year i would've called him a playmaker. 1/4 ain't bad but it's time to do it again you know what i mean?

[RunninRaven]

Originally Posted by KJ3

i don't think dunta is a playmaker. he's about as solid of a cover corner as you can ask for but i don't think he's the type of player that routinely changes how offenses play. what's the most interceptions he's ever had?

EDIT: it's 6. with 19 passes deflected, 3 forced fumbles, 3 sacks, 74 tackles with 14 assists. that was 2004, the only year i would've called him a playmaker. 1/4 ain't bad but it's time to do it again you know what i mean?

Yeah, but look at how many times teams threw at him. I swear, watching the games, you could go for what seemed like weeks at a time without a QB throwing in Dunta's direction. Now, that is partly because of the crap that has always been manning the other CB spot opposite Dunta, but also because he is so damn good. I think a team purposefully staying away from Dunta's side of the field is a perfect example of a playmaker. They are changing how they play because of him.

I wouldn't call him an elite cornerback (yet), but I would damn sure refer to him as a playmaker. And not just for his coverage skills either. He is very instrumental in run stopping on plays where the running back bounces to the outside.

Stats won't tell you everything.

Edit: Well, I've tried desperately now to locate a "Thrown At" statistic, but it seems no one keeps them. I maintain my belief that for the amount of attempts Dunta gets at either defending a pass or making an interception, he is as big a playmaker as just about any of the top cornerbacks. He just has fewer chances.

[papabear]

Originally Posted by RunninRaven

Yeah, but look at how many times teams threw at him. I swear, watching the games, you could go for what seemed like weeks at a time without a QB throwing in Dunta's direction. Now, that is partly because of the crap that has always been manning the other CB spot opposite Dunta, but also because he is so damn good. I think a team purposefully staying away from Dunta's side of the field is a perfect example of a playmaker. They are changing how they play because of him.

I wouldn't call him an elite cornerback (yet), but I would damn sure refer to him as a playmaker. And not just for his coverage skills either. He is very instrumental in run stopping on plays where the running back bounces to the outside.

Stats won't tell you everything.

I disagree with you about how much teams really stay away from him. There have been occasions where they might have picked on someone else (I wonder who), but that had as much to do with the play of the rest of the secondary as it did with Dunta. It's just one example, but the Titans had no problem going at Dunta with the game on the line....the game where we made the huge comeback and then let it slip away after taking the lead. That was one of those cases where you just have to say that there guy made a good play. It's not like he got beat, but he didn't knock it away either.

Like I said, that's just one play. I think if you went back and looked at the tape and tracked just how many times teams threw his direction you would be surprised. I'm not saying he's not a very good corner, but teams weren't terrified to throw to his side of the field either.

[painekiller]

I love Dunte and all but 11 ints in 57 games is not what I call a playmaker. Deion Sanders has playmaker stats, plus he can go to the house anytime he gets near a ball.

[KJ3]

Originally Posted by RunninRaven

Yeah, but look at how many times teams threw at him. I swear, watching the games, you could go for what seemed like weeks at a time without a QB throwing in Dunta's direction. Now, that is partly because of the crap that has always been manning the other CB spot opposite Dunta, but also because he is so damn good. I think a team purposefully staying away from Dunta's side of the field is a perfect example of a playmaker. They are changing how they play because of him.

I wouldn't call him an elite cornerback (yet), but I would damn sure refer to him as a playmaker. And not just for his coverage skills either. He is very instrumental in run stopping on plays where the running back bounces to the outside.

Stats won't tell you everything.

they tell enough. i totally agree with you that teams throw more at the (obviously, in this case) weaker cb but he does get his chances though and usually makes good on them. and even so, he still doesn't put up the kind of numbers that playmakers put up. we all love dunta, but he doesn't regularly change games. at least he hasn't in a few years...

Edit: Well, I've tried desperately now to locate a "Thrown At" statistic, but it seems no one keeps them. I maintain my belief that for the amount of attempts Dunta gets at either defending a pass or making an interception, he is as big a playmaker as just about any of the top cornerbacks. He just has fewer chances.

man, i hate to do it...i hate to do this to dunta....
~by year~ 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007
DUNTA- 6, 1, 2, 2
A.Cromartie- X, X, 0, 10 in his first real year
C. Bailey- 3, 8, 10, 3
A. Sameul 1, 3, 10, 6
E. Reed- 9, 1, 5, 7
D. Bly- 4, 6, 3, 5
R. Williams- 2, 3, 5, 2
C. Woodson- 1, 1, 8, 4
B. Dawkins- 4, 3, 4, 1

just a few well known guys who are more playmaker (in the int. department anyway) than dunta in dunta's 4 years. putting roy williams up there hurt me a little but i won't ignore truth for homeristic thoughts.

[edo783]

Originally Posted by KJ3

man, i hate to do it...i hate to do this to dunta....
~by year~ 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007
DUNTA- 6, 1, 2, 2
A.Cromartie- X, X, 0, 10 in his first real year
C. Bailey- 3, 8, 10, 3
A. Sameul 1, 3, 10, 6
E. Reed- 9, 1, 5, 7
D. Bly- 4, 6, 3, 5
R. Williams- 2, 3, 5, 2
C. Woodson- 1, 1, 8, 4
B. Dawkins- 4, 3, 4, 1

Those numbers do sort of support that Dunta isn't thrown on much. Look at the first year. That was when Glenn was our premo CB and they threw at Dunta a lot and he picked them off. Looks like they backed off once the saw what he could do and the had easier pickings with Faggens and Mr. Ole. The way we have been playing defense, where they are responsible for a side of the field probably means he isn't able to make those plays where a CB sort of freelances and goes to the other side during the play and winds up getting a pick. Some of those guys on the list kind of play like they a free safeties.

[RunninRaven]

The Titans game actually kind of makes my point for me. In that game, the reason why that play that Dunta gave up at the end was so surprising was because he had been solid all game long. There was a pass on him early where he gave up like 18 yards, but after that they were all short gains and he broke up a couple passes as well as made a tackle for a loss. He was having a great game, and then that last pass that he defended really well, but somehow that ball just managed to get through his hands. It sucked, but it was uncharacteristic, which is why I feel it makes my point.

You could argue that the opposing QB threw to the other side of the field because that other CB sucked, and that it wasn't because of DRob's skill, but there really isn't any way to prove that argument.

papabear, you say I would be surprised how many times he was thrown at. What do you think his "Thrown At" numbers are compared to other highly skilled CBs? Do you think he was thrown at more than half of them? Less? I'm hoping you can track down your old copy of the KC Joyner book and see what the figures were for 2006.

[Bigtinylittle]

Just from watching Dunte in games, I get the impression that when he is up against a much taller receiver, which happens a lot, he is athletic enough to break up the pass but not athletic enough to go up and take it away from him. On the rare occasion where he gets a chance to jump a route, I think he can do that as well as anyone in the league. I also think he is excellent on the blitz but because of team philosophy he hasn't gotten much of a chance to use his talents. Hopefully that philosophy will change somewhere down the road.

When he was opposite Faggins and it was 3rd down, it seemed like the other team almost NEVER threw to Dunte's man. Maybe because they were afraid Dunte would make a play.

[KJ3]

some of those cats ARE free safeties edo.

also, i have stated just as clearly as you have that i hold the same belief of dunta not being thrown at as much whenever he was the stronger of the two corners. however, the list i threw together in about five minutes are of guys who are no secret to me or the wide world of football. they were all still able to produce numbers reflecting their "playmaker" titles, so why hasn't dunta? ::ack this is killing me:: it's not like they only threw his way twice and he picked both of them, hell if i remember right one of his picks this year was off a tipped ball. anybody can pick a tip, very little cornerback-specific talents get involved in that. "playmaker" as i use it is more for the special athlete/gaudy number types. sportscenter highlight frequenters. this isn't what dunta is or really has ever been....

what he is: a smothering cover corner with some "ball skills", as ferocious as a tackler from the corner can be, lightning quick, all heart-terrific emotional leader, and hell on wheels blitzing. too bad he doesn't do much of that these days...

he does have some competent fellow defensive backfielders to protect him this go around though. maybe we will see more of the "playmaker" dunta like from his rookie season and less of the "people have to make an argument to prove he is a playmaker rather than just him being a playmaker and everyone knowing it" dunta.

[KJ3]

agggghhh.....

i feel like i'm ripping on dunta and i don't want that. so to compensate i have to make everyone remember the hit he put on the...titans?....tight end!! omg, that dude was a solid 40ish pounds more than dunta (taller too obviously) and dunta stopped him cold!!! i wasn't able to sit down for like the next 10 minutes because of his fearlessness!!!

[Bigtinylittle]

I really didn't feel you were ripping on Dunte, just making a pretty good argument. I just thought of another thing in Dunte's favor, though. A defensive back's ability to be a playmaker is in large part determined by how much pressure the defense is putting on the QB. When a QB is hurried, he tends to make poor throws or poor decisions, which a great CB can make him pay for. It would be interesting to know how many plays other top corners would be making if they played for a team like the Texans which does a poor job of pressuring the QB.

[RunninRaven]

Originally Posted by KJ3

some of those cats ARE free safeties edo.

also, i have stated just as clearly as you have that i hold the same belief of dunta not being thrown at as much whenever he was the stronger of the two corners. however, the list i threw together in about five minutes are of guys who are no secret to me or the wide world of football. they were all still able to produce numbers reflecting their "playmaker" titles, so why hasn't dunta?

How many of those guys had an opposing corner as bad as Faggins, though?

[Dancerdog]

I believe that Will Demps has one spot sewed up now. I don't see anyone supplanting him. The other spot is up for grabs. The intangible I am excited about is what effect Ray Rhodes will have on their play. Demps can lay the wood when he has a mind to. I would like to see some safety play that strikes fear in opposing WR's making a catch over the middle. Demps and Dunta Robinson type hitting. Can't wait for training camp. Should be some good battles with the depth we've built up.

[KJ3]

Originally Posted by RunninRaven

How many of those guys had an opposing corner as bad as Faggins, though?

as bad as petey? probably not. but it's not like champ bailey had stud guys across from him. dre bly never had much help until he was paired with bailey and that wasn't the duo from hell that it should be because the rest of the denver defense sucked last year.

asante sameul never had a huge amount of support across from him, though he did play on some tough all-around defenses.

[papabear]

Originally Posted by RunninRaven

Edit: Well, I've tried desperately now to locate a "Thrown At" statistic, but it seems no one keeps them.

KC Joyner usually tracks something like that, but you have to buy his book. I've got it from last year. I might get it again this year.....I'll try and remember to look and see what he's got on it in my older version, and if I buy the new one I will try to pass that along too.