QB Poll #1

[barrett]

Originally Posted by HPF Bob

That's fine and may be the correct answer. Just be prepared to own it if we get to the wild card game again and have to rely on our own version of Connor Cook to advance. And be prepared to hear more whining about how we're wasting J.J. Watt's career and not seriously addressing the QB position.

What do Kaep, Smokin' Jay, and a bunch of career backups have to do with wasting Watt's career? Who have you heard whining that we wasted his career by not signing more retreads or not trading for more backups? That's been our literal plan at QB the entire time we've been wasting his career.

[Arky]

#7.

Let's answer the Savage question once and for all....

[HPF Bob]

Originally Posted by barrett

What do Kaep, Smokin' Jay, and a bunch of career backups have to do with wasting Watt's career?

The first two options give us a playoff-experienced veteran who can be a short-term solution while whomever we draft gets up to speed. The others are just more-affordable options if Kaepernick and Cutler don't suit you.

Who have you heard whining that we wasted his career

It's been all over this board. Unless you believe Tom Brady will declare free agency or Peyton Manning comes out of retirement, these are the options we have to work with.

Tell me, oh wise one, where are we getting this Super-Bowl ready QB to start with the Texans this year? You're stuck with table scraps. Gotta make the best you can out of them.

[chuck]

Originally Posted by HPF Bob

Who have you heard whining that we wasted his career

Conveniently omitting

by not signing more retreads or not trading for more backups?

and therefore perverting the point entirely.

[barrett]

Originally Posted by chuck

Conveniently omitting



and therefore perverting the point entirely.

Yep. The idea that anyone will complain we didn't sign Kaep or Cutler is absurd. I have led the whining about QB, and all the whining has been entirely about us not drafting a guy.

Bob, you either have serious reading comprehension problems or you just unashamedly lie to make the facts fit the narrative you're most comfortable with.

[HPF Bob]

Would you be happier right now if we had taken Bridgewater or Bortles over Clowney? We took Kevin Johnson at #16 the following year and the next QB taken after him was Garrett Grayson at #76. Do you want him? Last year, they took Jacoby Jones 2.0 but they thought they already had their QB of the future so they loaded up on pass catchers. Should they have drafted Paxton Lynch or Christian Hackenberg?

[bikerack]

Originally Posted by HPF Bob

Would you be happier right now if we had taken Bridgewater or Bortles over Clowney? We took Kevin Johnson at #16 the following year and the next QB taken after him was Garrett Grayson at #76. Do you want him? Last year, they took Jacoby Jones 2.0 but they thought they already had their QB of the future so they loaded up on pass catchers. Should they have drafted Paxton Lynch or Christian Hackenberg?

I'd be happier if they took Jimmy G. over Su'a-Filo...<backing away from thread slowly>

[HPF Bob]

Originally Posted by bikerack

I'd be happier if they took Jimmy G. over Su'a-Filo...<backing away from thread slowly>

So would you trade for him now, knowing the Patriots want a #1 pick in return?